He arrives home with Current Girlfriend. When he gets there, Old Girlfriend is waiting. OG opens the passenger side door of his car, pulls CG from the car and assaults her. CG is taken to the hospital and treated for the injuries she sustained at the hands of OG. CG files a criminal complaint against OG. The trial judge finds a violation of the New Jersey Prevention of Domestic Violence Act. The Appellate Division reverses. R. P. v. Somerset, New Jersey App. Div., October 20, 2009